The “Second Translation Controversy” and Its Question of Inculturation in the History of Catholicism in China

Bai Guoliang

International Journal of Catholic Studies ›› 2025, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (16) : 33-50.

PDF(1769 KB)
PDF(1769 KB)
International Journal of Catholic Studies ›› 2025, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (16) : 33-50. DOI: 10.30239/IJCS.202506_(16).0003
Special Feature: Chinese Culture and Cultural Theology

The “Second Translation Controversy” and Its Question of Inculturation in the History of Catholicism in China

  • Bai Guoliang
Author information +
History +

Abstract

How can the Gospel be better spread in China so that the Chinese people can better understand and accept Christianity? This is a question that countless missionaries and Christians in China have pondered and worked on since Matteo Ricci. The “Chinese Rite Controversy” had a significant impact on the development of the Church in China. Although the dispute eventually subsided after the intervention of the Holy See, it did not disappear completely. This article discusses the arguments and objectives of missionaries in the mid-19th century regarding the use of Chinese classical terms Tian and Shangdi to refer to God. There was no right or wrong in the views of the two sides, but only a manifestation of their responsibility and love for the local church. This paper specifically analyzes the dialogue between the Lazarist Bishop Joseph-Martial Mouly and Bishop Emmanuel-Jean-Francois Verrolles of the Missions étrangers de Paris (MEP) on this issue, reflecting their concerns in the mission in China and examining the significance of their theology of inculturation and missionary strategy.

Key words

Inculturation / God / Shangdi / Tian / The Chinese Rite Controversy / Mgr. Joseph-Martial Mouly / Mgr. Emmanuel-Jean-François Verrolles

Cite this article

Download Citations
Bai Guoliang. The “Second Translation Controversy” and Its Question of Inculturation in the History of Catholicism in China[J]. International Journal of Catholic Studies. 2025, 0(16): 33-50 https://doi.org/10.30239/IJCS.202506_(16).0003
PDF(1769 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/